Sep 20, 2007
Long time Sneed blog readers know my position on God. I don't think that there is a God. I might be wrong though. I for sure don't see any evidence that if God created the universe, He cares one wit about our day-to-day lives. The existence of God simply doesn't matter to me. But this rant is not really about God, so I'll stop.
My friend is in the middle of a trying time. One of her toddlers has a heart defect and will have surgery to correct the problem...heart surgery. Think about that for a minute. A tiny tot is having her heart cut open so that the doctor can repair a flaw. Very scary stuff, even if it almost always works out just fine. She is worried and that may be an understatement.
She is also struggling with the reactions of others to her angst. Some people are even offering platitudes, religious thought and cutesy motivational shinola in an effort to allay her fears or as a weapon to crush them.
Here's a clue. She gets to be worried out of her mind and no amount of platitudinous bullsh*t will or should, change that one bit. She's a mom and she gets to be worried about her baby. Offering up crap like "finding the good in every situation" or "give it to God", trivializes the serious of the matter and disrespects her feelings.
Anyone who wouldn't be worried under these circumstances, either has no feelings or has stuffed them way down deep inside. Or they are just an idiot. Anyone who tells you that they have the peace that passes all understanding in this situation is just full of crap. They mistake their good fortune for insight, the smoothness of their life as proof of God's love for them.
One thing that is decidedly unhelpful is for people to say that things will turn out alright. That is of course, unless they can actually predict the future. Then it is real helpful. My experience is that most people can't predict the future.
People are telling my friend how to feel (don't worry) and how to deal with her feelings (pray, my dear, or be optimistic). I've been there and I can tell you, it doesn't help. There is nothing anyone can say that makes things better for a parent who has to put the life of her child in the hands another. Even if the other is a highly-trained and skilled surgeon who has done this procedure dozens of times. Until the doctor says, "She did great and things look real good", worry is the order of the day.
When our little guy was killed a lot of well-meaning people said a lot of really stupid stuff to us. Sometimes they were just trying to say something to bring comfort to the situation. Other times they were talking.
Some of the most meaningless platitudes were offered by religious people. More than one knucklehead said that God has a plan. Well yeah, he planned to kill my grandson. As plans go, I have to tell you that one sucks. So, I just pass on asking that this God take my pain away. If He exists, he has done quite enough.
Sometimes people will tell you that God doesn't give you more than you can handle. What a load. Sometimes you do get more than you can handle. Not killing yourself is not evidence of handling adversity. Just surviving day-to-day isn't evidence either. Sometimes life deals you a body blow that changes you forever, and not for the better. If you believe in God and that gives you some measure of comfort, good for you. Me, not so much.
So, at the end of the day, bad things happen to good people, as the man said. I don't think it is some part of a divine plan, it is plain old lousy breaks. Sometimes things can be done to fix it and sometimes they can't. The darkest moment of life for a parent is to face the death of their child, even if it is the remotest of chances that the worst will happen. We fear the worst because we are human and our children are the most important thing in our lives.
So, here's a tip. When you have a friend or loved one in crisis, don't make false assurances or offer silly platitudes. Just let them know you are there if they need help and then shut up.
Things in this blog represented to be fact, may or may not actually be true. The writer is frequently wrong, sometimes just full of it, but always judgmental and cranky
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
You know what would help? If we all forwarded her one of those inspirational emails.
Ha, Kurt.
THANK YOU for getting it! I love you tons, Merle.
I know we have different views of the existence of God, but we have a lot in common when it comes to how we feel about the things "well meaning" people (often Christians) have to say.
If I lived a million more years, I'd never be wise enough to give you a satisfactory answer about why your grandson was taken from you. Especially not in the manner he was taken. It's not fair. It will never be. Nothing anyone will ever say can make a difference, and I think I'd forever be changed for the worse if it happened to me. It makes me want to scream and cry, and I didn't even know him. I just know that as a child, he deserved better than that. And as his family, you guys deserved better. My heart hurts soooo much for your family. It's incomprehensible.
I couldn't agree more that not committing suicide is no sign of strength or being able to handle what "God" has sent your way. That's total BULL SHIT! Pardon my language. As a believer in God, I don't believe for a second God wants us to endure that kind of agony to make us stronger. That makes no sense. People are idiots. People say I'm so strong to get through all the things I've gotten through in life. Was I given a choice? Did I miss that option somewhere? That's not strength. That's called having no choice.
You are absolutely right. The best thing to do is just tell the person going through the pain that you hurt for them and realize there are no words to make it better. These stupid positive attitude makes all the difference emails, etc. are like rubbing salt in a gaping wound.
I think Christians can be their own worst enemy. Telling you God had a plan when your grandson was killed is SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO INSANE! It implies God planned it! Why WOULD you want to believe in a God who planned to take your grandson from you??? It's so wrong it makes me sick. You have so many horrible stories of your experiences with Christians that I don't blame you one bit for thinking we're a bunch of lunatics. I'm really sorry, Merle. I wish I could defend them, but there are no words to erase the damage that has already been done. I'm just really, really sorry.
We don't have to see eye to eye on religion. I just know I care about your pain and wish I could do something to change it. I think you're a wonderful human being, and you deserve peace and happiness as much as anyone else I know. I'm pulling for you, too, kid. ;)
Ahhh haaaa Kurt!!
Anyhoo Mr. Sneed...
this was a gahhhreat post....
You are a goooood friend...
and
since you say you don't believe in God..
I am going to pray extra hard for you b/c I yuv you!
Oh.. and people do just say the stupidest things...
all I can think is:
they don't know what to say...
they need to read your blog...
it's perfect...
and...
I still just feel for you sooo much over your loss..
it's simply unimaginable....
Is stupidest even a word?
So true.
My friends were much more reasonable when I was in a similar situation. Still, do I suddenly deserve flowers when my best friend is dead? Weren't things already unfair enough?
I finally realized they were doing these stupid things instead of things that would actually help because nothing they could do would help. I really couldn't think of anything they could do. Other than tiny things like letting me cry in front of them without getting all weirded out.
So after that I decided to change my interpretation of other people's responses. No matter what they did, I interpreted that as meaning that if they could have done anything to help, they would have done that instead, that they wish this hadn't happened, and that they are sorry that my life sucks right now because they care about me.
I'm sure some people see things like this merely as opportunities to push their religion or other agendas, and they really don't care. But then some people find that once they can make themselves believe that God would never give them more than they could handle, they find it easier to pull up that strength that you have no choice but to pull up, etc., and so they really think they are offering helpful advice.
Best wishes to your friend during this scary time.
Merle: You're right, of course. There really is almost nothing appropriate to say in such situations. People are just trying to be helpful, to express support -- they just don't always see how their words of support can actually be hurtful.
Post a Comment